NinjaTrader vs TradeStation: Zomwe zili bwino

1. Pulogalamu Yogulitsa

A malonda nsanja ndi pachimake mapulogalamu kuti traders amagwiritsa ntchito kupeza misika, kuchita maoda, kusanthula ma chart, ndikuwongolera maakaunti awo. Malo abwino ogulitsa ayenera kukhala odalirika, ofulumira, osavuta kugwiritsa ntchito, komanso otsika mtengo. Zotsatirazi ndizomwe zimasiyanitsa nsanja zonse ziwiri:

1.1. Chiyankhulo cha Wogwiritsa Ntchito ndi Kusavuta Kugwiritsa Ntchito

Mawonekedwe ogwiritsira ntchito komanso kugwiritsa ntchito mosavuta malo ochitira malonda angakhale ndi zotsatira zazikulu pazochitika zamalonda ndi ntchito. Mawonekedwe ogwiritsira ntchito opangidwa bwino ayenera kukhala mwachilengedwe, makonda, komanso omvera. Iyeneranso kupereka mwayi wosavuta kuzinthu zofunika kwambiri ndi ntchito za nsanja.

NinjaTrader:

NinjaTrader ali zojambula bwino, kutanthauza kuti traders amatha kutsegula mawindo angapo ndikuwongolera malinga ndi zomwe amakonda. Zenera lililonse limatha kuwonetsa zidziwitso zamitundu yosiyanasiyana, monga ma chart, zolembera, zowunikira msika, nkhani, ndi zina. NinjaTrader imalolanso traders kuti pangani malo ogwirira ntchito ndi kuwasunga kuti adzagwiritse ntchito mtsogolo.

TradeMalo:

TradeStation, kumbali ina, ili ndi zambiri Integrated kapangidwe, kutanthauza traders amatha kupeza zambiri ndi ntchito kuchokera pawindo lalikulu limodzi. Zenera lalikulu limakhala ndi ma tabo angapo, monga ma chart, matrix, scanner, radar screen, ndi zina zambiri. TradeStation imalolanso traders kuti pangani masanjidwe mwamakonda ndi kuwasunga kuti adzagwiritse ntchito mtsogolo.

Onse nsanja amapereka a mkulu mlingo wa makonda ndi makonda. Traders imatha kusintha mitundu, mafonti, kukula kwake, ndi malo azinthu zosiyanasiyana pazenera. Athanso kuwonjezera kapena kuchotsa zida, mindandanda yazakudya, mabatani, ndi zizindikiro. Komabe, ena traders atha kupeza NinjaTradekusinthasintha komanso kusinthasintha, pamene ena angakonde TradeNjira yama station ndiyosavuta komanso yosavuta.

Onse nsanja alinso ndi mfundo yopindika, makamaka kwa oyamba kumene. Traders ayenera kudziwa bwino mawonekedwe a nsanja iliyonse, ntchito zake, ndi mawu ofotokozera. Ayeneranso kuphunzira momwe angayendetse, kukonza, ndi kugwiritsa ntchito nsanja. Mapulatifomu onsewa amapereka maphunziro, makanema, ndi maupangiri othandizira traders kuyamba.

Nayi tebulo lomwe limafotokoza mwachidule kusiyana kwakukulu pakati pa NinjaTrader ndi TradeStation malinga ndi mawonekedwe a ogwiritsa ntchito komanso yosavuta kugwiritsa ntchito:

1.2. Kuthekera kwa Charting ndi Kusintha Mwamakonda Anu

Charting ndi chimodzi mwazinthu zofunika kwambiri papulatifomu yamalonda. Ma chart amalola traders kuti onani misika yosiyanasiyana yamitengo ndi zida zamagulu ndi machitidwe. Ma chart amayatsanso traders kuti ntchito kusanthula luso, yomwe ndi phunziro la khalidwe lamtengo wapatali lakale kuti liwonetsere mayendedwe amtsogolo amtengo wapatali ndi zomwe zikuchitika.

Onse NinjaTrader ndi TradeKupereka kwa station luso lapamwamba lojambula ndi zosankha makonda. Traders angasankhe kuchokera ku mitundu yosiyanasiyana ya matchati, monga choyikapo nyali, mipiringidzo, mzere, dera, renko, heikin-ashi, ndi zina zotero. Onse nsanja amalola traders kuti kupanga ma chart angapo ndi kuzilumikiza pamodzi kuti zisinthe mosavuta ndi kulunzanitsa. Komabe, pali kusiyana pakati pa nsanja ziwirizi potengera mawonekedwe a charting ndi magwiridwe antchito.

NinjaTrader:

NinjaTrader ndi zina zamphamvu komanso zosinthika charting injini, zomwe zimalola traders kuti apange masitaelo a tchati, zizindikiro, ndi njira. NinjaTrader imathandiziranso nthawi zambiri ndi kusanthula kwa zida zambiri, kutanthauza kuti traders imatha kuphimba mafelemu anthawi ndi zida zosiyanasiyana patchati chomwecho. NinjaTrader ilinso ndi mawonekedwe apadera otchedwa Tchati Trader, yomwe imalola traders kuti akhazikitse ndikuwongolera maoda mwachindunji kuchokera patchati.

TradeMalo:

TradeStation, kumbali ina, ili ndi zambiri wosavuta kugwiritsa ntchito komanso mwachilengedwe ma charting mawonekedwe, omwe amalola traders kuti mupeze ndikusintha ma chart ndi zizindikiro mosavuta. TradeStation ilinso ndi gawo lotchedwa EasyLanguage, yomwe imalola traders kuti apange zizindikiro ndi njira zomwe zimagwiritsidwa ntchito pogwiritsa ntchito chinenero chosavuta. Kuphatikiza apo, ili ndi mwayi wina wotchedwa Chithunzi cha Radar, yomwe imalola traders kuyang'anira ndikusanthula misika ndi zida zingapo munthawi yeniyeni.

Onse nsanja kupereka lalikulu laibulale ya zizindikiro zaumisiri zomangidwa kale, monga kusinthana maulendo, oscillators, mizere yamayendedwe, etc. Amalolanso traders kupanga awo zizindikiro zanu pogwiritsa ntchito zilankhulo zawo zamapulogalamu. Komabe, ena traders atha kupeza NinjaTrader zambiri zosunthika komanso zamphamvu, pomwe ena angapeze TradeMalo opezekapo komanso osavuta.

Nayi tebulo lomwe limafotokoza mwachidule kusiyana kwakukulu pakati pa NinjaTrader ndi TradeStation malinga ndi kuthekera kwa ma charting ndi makonda:

1.3. Zizindikiro Zaumisiri ndi Zida Zobwereranso

Zizindikiro zaumisiri ndi masamu masamu zomwe zimagwiritsidwa ntchito pamtengo ndi kuchuluka kwa msika kapena chida. Zizindikiro zaukadaulo zimathandizira traders kuti azindikire zomwe zikuchitika, mawonekedwe, ma sign, ndi mwayi pamsika. Zizindikiro zaukadaulo zitha kugawidwa m'magulu osiyanasiyana, monga mayendedwe, patsogolo, kusasinthasintha, volume, etc.

Kubwereranso ndi njira ya kuyesa njira yamalonda kapena dongosolo pazambiri zakale kuti awone momwe amagwirira ntchito komanso phindu lake. Kubwerera kumbuyo kumathandiza traders kukhathamiritsa, kuyeretsa, ndikutsimikizira malingaliro awo amalonda ndi malingaliro awo. Kubwerera kumbuyo kungathandizenso traders amapewa kukondera mochulukira, kukondera, komanso kukondera kwa data.

Onse NinjaTrader ndi TradeKupereka kwa station zizindikiro zambiri zaumisiri ndi zida backtesting. Traders akhoza kusankha kuchokera mazana a zizindikiro zomangidwa kale zomwe zimapezeka pa nsanja iliyonse. Akhozanso kupanga awo zizindikiro zachizolowezi pogwiritsa ntchito zilankhulo zawo zamapulogalamu. Onse nsanja amalola traders kuti agwiritse ntchito zizindikiro zingapo pa tchati chomwecho ndikusintha magawo awo ndi zoikamo. Komabe, pali kusiyana pakati pa mapulaneti awiriwa ponena za zizindikiro zaumisiri ndi zida zobwerera kumbuyo.

NinjaTrader:

NinjaTrader ndi zina injini zapamwamba komanso zapamwamba zobwerera kumbuyo, yomwe imalola traders kuchita zoyeserera zakale, zoyenda patsogolo, ndi Monte Carlo. NinjaTrader imathandiziranso kukhathamiritsa kwa chibadwa komanso zolinga zambiri, kutanthauza kuti traders atha kupeza kuphatikiza koyenera kwa magawo ndi zolinga za njira zawo. NinjaTrader ilinso ndi gawo lotchedwa Strategy Analyzer, yomwe imalola traders kusanthula ndi kufananiza magwiridwe antchito ndi ziwerengero za njira zawo.

TradeMalo:

Tradestation, kumbali ina, ili ndi zambiri yosavuta ndi yowongoka backtesting mawonekedwe, yomwe imalola traders kuyesa mbiri yakale komanso kupita patsogolo. TradeStation imathandizanso kukhathamiritsa kwa cholinga chimodzi, kutanthauza kuti traders atha kupeza mtengo wokwanira wa gawo limodzi kapena cholinga cha njira zawo. TradeStation ilinso ndi gawo lotchedwa Strategy Performance Report, yomwe imalola traders kuti awone ndikutumiza kunja magwiridwe antchito ndi ziwerengero za njira zawo.

Nayi tebulo lomwe limafotokoza mwachidule kusiyana kwakukulu pakati pa NinjaTrader ndi TradeStation malinga ndi zizindikiro zamakono ndi zida backtesting:

1.4. Kuthamanga Kwadongosolo ndi Kudalirika

Kuthamanga kwa maoda ndi kudalirika ndizofunikira kwambiri pakuchita traders ndani trade pafupipafupi komanso m'mabuku akuluakulu. Kuthamanga kwa dongosolo kumatanthawuza momwe nsanja yogulitsira ingatumizire, kulandira, ndi kuyitanitsa kumsika. Kudalirika kwadongosolo kumatanthawuza momwe nsanja yamalonda ingagwiritsire ntchito moyenera komanso yolondola Malinga ndi trader malangizo ndi ziyembekezo.

Onse NinjaTrader ndi TradeStation imapereka mphamvu zoyendetsera mwachangu komanso zodalirika. Traders angasankhe mitundu yosiyanasiyana ya dongosolo, monga msika, malire, kusiya, kusiya malire, trailing stop, etc. Komabe, pali kusiyana pakati pa nsanja ziwiri malinga ndi liwiro la kuphedwa ndi kudalirika.

NinjaTrader:

NinjaTrader ali njira yowongoka bwino komanso yowongoka bwino, yomwe imalola traders kuti mugwirizane ndi angapo brokers ndi opereka deta. NinjaTrader imathandiziranso kasamalidwe ka dongosolo la seva, zomwe zikutanthauza kuti malamulo amasungidwa ndi kuchitidwa pa brokerseva osati pa trader kompyuta. Izi zimachepetsa chiopsezo kulephera kwa dongosolo chifukwa cha netiweki kapena zovuta za hardware.

TradeMalo:

Tradestation, kumbali ina, ili ndi a njira yoyendetsera bwino kwambiri komanso yapakati, kutanthauza kuti traders ayenera kugwiritsa ntchito TradeStation ngati yawo broker ndi wopereka data. Imathandizanso kasamalidwe ka dongosolo la kasitomala, zomwe zikutanthauza kuti malamulo amasungidwa ndi kuchitidwa pa trader kompyuta osati pa brokerseva ya. Izi zimawonjezera kudalira ndi kusatetezeka kwa trader ndondomeko.

Nayi tebulo lomwe limafotokoza mwachidule kusiyana kwakukulu pakati pa NinjaTrader ndi TradeStation malinga ndi liwiro kuphedwa ndi kudalirika:

1.5. Kugulitsa Mapepala ndi Zofananira

Kugulitsa mapepala ndi kuyerekezera kumalola traders kuti trade ndi ndalama zenizeni komanso momwe msika umayendera mukugwiritsabe ntchito zomwezo ndi ntchito za nsanja yamalonda.

Onse NinjaTrader ndi TradeStation imapereka malonda a mapepala ndi mawonekedwe oyerekeza. Traders amatha kupanga ndikugwiritsa ntchito maakaunti ogulitsa mapepala osiyana ndi maakaunti awo ogulitsa. Komabe, pali kusiyana kwina pakati pa nsanja ziwirizi pankhani ya malonda a pepala ndi mawonekedwe oyerekeza.

NinjaTrader:

NinjaTrader ali injini yofananira yowona komanso yokwanira, yomwe imalola traders kutengera zochitika zosiyanasiyana zamsika, monga kutsetsereka, ma komisheni, latency, ndi zina. NinjaTrader imathandiziranso bwerezani mode, yomwe imalola traders kuti muyesenso mbiri yakale ya msika ndi trade ngati ndi moyo. NinjaTrader ilinso ndi gawo lotchedwa Kubwereza Msika, yomwe imalola traders kutsitsa ndikuseweranso deta yamsika kuchokera zosiyanasiyana brokers ndi opereka deta.

TradeMalo:

TradeStation, kumbali ina, ili ndi a zambiri zofunika ndi zochepa kayeseleledwe injini, zomwe sizimawerengera zinthu zina zamsika, monga slippage, commissions, latency, etc. TradeMasiteshoni nawonso sagwirizana ndi replay mode, kutanthauza kuti traders akhoza kokha trade ndi nthawi yeniyeni kapena deta yochedwa msika. TradeStation ilibenso mawonekedwe ngati Market Replay, zomwe zikutanthauza kuti traders atha kugwiritsa ntchito deta yamsika yoperekedwa ndi TradePoyimira.

Nayi tebulo lomwe limafotokoza mwachidule kusiyana kwakukulu pakati pa NinjaTrader ndi TradePotengera malonda a pepala ndi mawonekedwe oyerekeza:

2. Maphunziro a Chuma ndi Misika

Maphunziro a asset ndi misika ndi mitundu ya zida zachuma ndi kusinthanitsa kuti traders angathe trade pa nsanja yamalonda. Magulu azinthu ndi misika ali ndi mawonekedwe osiyanasiyana, monga malire, kusinthasintha, mphamvu, mmphepete, Ndi zina zotero.

Onse NinjaTrader ndi TradeMasiteshoni amapereka mwayi wopita kumagulu osiyanasiyana azinthu ndi misika. Traders angathe trade makamaka zam'tsogolo, zosankha, ndi forex pa nsanja zonse ziwiri. Komabe, pali kusiyana pakati pa nsanja ziwirizi pankhani yamagulu azinthu ndi misika.

NinjaTrader:

NinjaTrader ali nsanja yosinthika komanso yotseguka, yomwe imalola traders kuti mugwirizane ndi angapo brokers ndi opereka deta. NinjaTrader imathandiziranso malonda a micro future, omwe ndi mapangano ang'onoang'ono omwe amafunikira ndalama zochepa komanso zoopsa. Pulatifomu ilinso ndi a SuperDOM mawonekedwe, yomwe imalola traders kuwona ndi trade Kuzama kwa msika wa chida chilichonse ndi buku la dongosolo.

TradeMalo:

TradeStation, kumbali ina, ili ndi nsanja yotsekedwa, kutanthauza kuti traders ayenera kugwiritsa ntchito TradeStation ngati yawo broker ndi wopereka data. TradeStation nawonso sigwirizana ndi malonda a micro futures, kutanthauza kuti traders ayenera trade mapangano okhazikika omwe amafunikira ndalama zambiri komanso chiopsezo. Komabe, ili ndi gawo lotchedwa masanjidwewo, yomwe imalola traders kuwona ndi trade kuzama kwa msika ndi buku la dongosolo la chida chilichonse.

Nayi tebulo lomwe limafotokoza mwachidule kusiyana kwakukulu pakati pa NinjaTrader ndi TradeMasiteshoni malinga ndi makalasi azinthu ndi misika:

3. Malipiro ndi Makomiti

Malipiro ndi ma komisheni ndi ndalama kuti traders ayenera kulipira kuti agwiritse ntchito nsanja yamalonda ndikupeza misika. Malipiro ndi ma komisheni amatha kukhudza kwambiri phindu ndi magwiridwe antchito a traders, makamaka yogwira traders ndani trade pafupipafupi komanso m'mabuku akuluakulu.

Onse NinjaTrader ndi TradeMalipiro amawayilesi ndi ma komisheni pazantchito zawo ndi zinthu zawo. Traders ayenera kulipira makomisheni ogulitsa pa chilichonse trade amachitira pa nsanja. Komabe, pali kusiyana pakati pa nsanja ziwirizi pankhani ya chindapusa ndi ma komisheni.

NinjaTrader:

NinjaTrader ali wopikisana kwambiri komanso wowonekera mitengo dongosolo, amene amalola traders kusankha kuchokera ku mapulani osiyanasiyana amakomisheni ndi zosankha zamitengo. NinjaTrader imaperekanso chilolezo chaulere chamoyo wonse kwa nsanja yake, tanthauzo traders amatha kugwiritsa ntchito popanda kulipira chindapusa chilichonse. Komanso, amapereka nthawi yeniyeni yaulere ndi mbiri msika data yamagulu ena azinthu ndi misika.

TradeMalo:

TradeStation, kumbali ina, ili ndi zambiri zovuta komanso zosinthika mitengo yamitengo, zomwe zimatengera mtundu wa akaunti, gulu lazachuma, msika, ndi malonda. TradeStation komanso amalipira chindapusa cha nsanja pakugwiritsa ntchito nsanja yake, yomwe imatha kuchotsedwa kapena kuchepetsedwa kutengera kuchuluka kwa malonda ndi kuchuluka kwa akaunti.

Nayi tebulo lomwe limafotokoza mwachidule kusiyana kwakukulu pakati pa NinjaTrader ndi TradePotengera chindapusa ndi ma komisheni:

4. Kafukufuku ndi Maphunziro

Kafukufuku ndi maphunziro ndi zofunika mbali traders omwe akufuna kukhala osinthidwa ndikudziwitsidwa zamayendedwe amsika ndi zomwe zikuchitika. Zimathandiza traders kuti aphunzire maluso ndi njira zatsopano ndikuwongolera magwiridwe antchito awo ndi zotsatira zake.

Onse NinjaTrader ndi TradeMa station amapereka kafukufuku ndi maphunziro. Traders amatha kupeza ndikugwiritsa ntchito zida zosiyanasiyana zofufuzira ndi zothandizira zomwe zimapezeka papulatifomu iliyonse. Athanso kutenga nawo mbali ndikuphunzira kuchokera ku ma webinars, maphunziro, ndi maphunziro omwe amaperekedwa ndi nsanja iliyonse. Komabe, pali kusiyana pakati pa nsanja ziwirizi pankhani ya kafukufuku ndi maphunziro.

NinjaTrader:

NinjaTrader ndi zina okhazikika komanso apadera kafukufuku ndi maphunziro nsanja makamaka yolunjika za tsogolo ndi forex malonda. NinjaTrader ilinso ndi gawo lotchedwa NinjaScript, yomwe imalola traders kuti apange zizindikiro, njira, ndi zowonjezera pogwiritsa ntchito chinenero cha C #-based programming. Ilinso ndi mbali yotchedwa NinjaTrader Ecosystem, omwe ndi gulu la otukula gulu lachitatu, aphunzitsi, ndi alangizi.

TradeMalo:

Tradestation, kumbali ina, ili ndi a kafukufuku wambiri komanso wosiyanasiyana wofufuza ndi maphunziro, yomwe imakhudza magulu osiyanasiyana azinthu ndi misika. TradeStation ilinso ndi gawo lotchedwa EasyLanguage, yomwe imalola traders kuti apange zizindikiro ndi njira zachizolowezi. Lilinso ndi mbali ina yotchedwa TradeStation Yunivesite, yomwe ndi malo ophunzirira pa intaneti omwe amapereka maphunziro, makanema, zolemba, ndi zochitika.

Nayi tebulo lomwe limafotokoza mwachidule kusiyana kwakukulu pakati pa NinjaTrader ndi TradePotengera kafukufuku ndi maphunziro:

5. Community ndi Thandizo

Community ndi chithandizo zimathandizanso traders amathetsa zovuta zilizonse zomwe angakumane nazo pogwiritsa ntchito nsanja yamalonda. Itha kugawidwa m'magulu osiyanasiyana, monga mabwalo ogwiritsa ntchito, chithandizo chamagulu, ntchito zamakasitomala, komanso zomwe ogwiritsa ntchito akumana nazo.

Onse NinjaTrader ndi TradeMasiteshoni amapereka anthu amdera komanso zothandizira. Traders amatha kulowa ndikujowina ma forum ndi madera osiyanasiyana omwe amapezeka papulatifomu iliyonse. Angathenso kulandira ndi kupereka chithandizo chamagulu ndi ndemanga kuchokera kwa ena traders ndi akatswiri. Komabe, pali kusiyana kwina pakati pa nsanja ziwirizi malinga ndi dera komanso mawonekedwe othandizira.

NinjaTrader:

NinjaTrader imakhala yogwira ntchito komanso yothandiza wosuta Forum ndi dera, yomwe imayendetsedwa ndikuthandizidwa ndi boma la NinjaTradegulu lothandizira. Inunso kupeza mwayi kwa Gulu Lothandizira, lomwe ndi bwalo lodzipatulira la ogwiritsa ntchito kufunsa ndi kuyankha mafunso, lipoti ndi kuthetsa mavuto, ndikupempha ndi kupereka malingaliro.

TradeMalo:

TradeStation, kumbali ina, ili ndi zambiri kungokhala chete komanso kochepa kwa ogwiritsa ntchito ndi gulu, yomwe siimayendetsedwa kapena kuthandizidwa ndi gulu lothandizira. TradeStation sapereka zinthu ngati NinjaTrader Support Forum kapena NinjaTrader Ecosystem, zomwe zikutanthauza kuti ogwiritsa ntchito amayenera kufufuza ndikupeza zinthu ndi ntchito za chipani chachitatu TradeOgwiritsa ntchito pa station.

Nayi tebulo lomwe limafotokoza mwachidule kusiyana kwakukulu pakati pa NinjaTrader ndi TradeMasiteshoni malinga ndi dera komanso mawonekedwe othandizira: